"Great Place to Eat!"
Great evening - we biked there from our hotel, had the entire patio outside to ourselves. The inside was full but we were able to occupy the entire outdoor patio with the fountain, which was lovely. Food was terrific, but portions are HUGE. They don't take reservations but we did not have trouble getting seated.
Visited March 2015
"A Very Good Restaurant"
This is the finest restaurant we found in Islamorada. The food was great and a good value for the quantity. The salads are exceptional and all food was of highest quality. The folks know how to prepare a meal.
Visited March 2015
"Food was fabulous and so was the service"
My husband and I went out for dinner and heard this place was awesome. Well, it was. We started off with the lobster mac and cheese. It was the creamiest and most delishious we have ever had. We also had the goat cheese and beet salad. It was perfect. He had the king prime rib and I had the rib eye steak. They were so tender and cooked to perfection. The service was quick and we didn't have to wait to be seated. I would recommend this restaurant highly for great food. It is not on the water but it is a nice place to go for great food.
Visited March 2015
"Favorite Food in Islamorada"
Food was outstanding! service was great and restaurant was very clean. Best food on the Island. Lots of history and many years of serving travelers shows. ~ TripAdvisor.com review July 23, 2014
Just stopped for a quick lunch, but very very good food, great service, outstanding menu. Would love to stop for dinner some time, just not enough time this trip. ~ Trip Advisor.com reviewed July 2014
"Great breakfast & dinner at the Green Turtle Inn!!!"
We always make a point to hit the Green Turtle for at least one of our meals when we visit Islamorada. After eating fish for lunch and dinner for several days, I always look forward to their prime rib on Saturday night. We usuallly hit them up for breakfast on our last day before heading home. The French toast is AWESOME! This place is a little more upscale than many in the area. I wouldn't wear a tank top but shorts and flip flops are still quite appropriate. They get busy on the holidays, so better make reservations! ~ Trip Advisor.com reviewed July 2014
“Great food. Nice atmosphere. As soon as the door closes behind you your nose will let you know you're in for a nice meal."
Loved the conch fritters and the yellowtail catch-o-the day "Sid" style. My girlfriend has a food allergy and they were the most accommodating restaurant we've ever been to. I'll definitely be back. ~ TripAdvisor.com
"Great breakfast and atmosphere"
Great place...Lots of choice on the menu so every taste catered for with quality food and drinks on offer. Staff helpful and friendly. Easy to find with plenty of parking - ideal for anyone staying at cheeca lodge as within easy walking distance. Clearly a favorite with locals a swell as visitors which is always a good sign. ~ TripAdvisor.com
“Best Breakfast - reasonably priced."
We spent three days in Islamorada and we ate at the Green Turtle Inn two mornings for breakfast. It was fabulous and the prices were very reasonable!! I highly recommend the Key West Eggs Benedict. It is delicious! Season begins around Christmas time so I imagine it gets pretty crowded in the winter time. But even if you have to wait for a seat, it is well worth it. The staff was very friendly and the atmosphere was warm and inviting. The orange juice was delicious (although a little on the expensive end) and the portions were very satisfying. Hint: Order the conch and eggs if you are extra hungry! ~ TripAdvisor.com
Four Stars from Yelp
“This place has been here forever. My Dad ate there in 1950!! It is way updated and way upscale (for the Keys) and better than ever (says 88 yr old Dad). Great menu, beautiful renovation, excellent service. Our favorite place." ~ Yelp.com
“Great food and atmosphere!"
I highly recommend this restaurant. My friends and family had traditional Thanksgiving dinner there. It was a great way to spend Thanksgiving. Everyone had a fantastic time. Everything was well prepared. The atmosphere was fun and happy. It is really an adorable place. ~ TripAdvisor.com
I have only ever visited this restaurant recently for breakfast but it is my favourite breakfast in the Keys. We call it our 'grown up' breakfast place and leave the children behind. Generally we have found the service good and the food excellent. ~ TripAdvisor.com
Five Stars from Yelp
“At first, I thought this place was a hotel and to my surprise it was a fabulous restaurant that has the best brunch in Islamorada! The service is excellent!! ~ Yelp.com